Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Building one grading and salary system across five sites and multiple works councils in a financial services operations unit

Industry
Financial services (consumer finance) operations
Region
Germany (five locations)
Size
1,500+ employees
Best for
Multi-site, unionised organisations consolidating merger-driven pay practices into one framework
247
positions graded with gradar
8
job families with parallel career paths
5
sites, each with its own works council
3
negotiated company agreements
01 Context

Starting point

A German consumer-finance operations unit, grown through mergers and spread across five sites, replaced fragmented location-specific pay rules with one grading and salary-band system, agreed with five separate works councils.

Client profile

The client was an operations unit in the financial services (consumer financing) sector in Germany, with more than 1,500 employees. It was a bilingual organisation, working in both English and German, and operated across five locations. Parts of the workforce were covered by collective (tariff) arrangements, and each site had its own works council.

The unit had grown partly through mergers. As a result, it had accumulated many positions without a coherent structure, and pay rules differed from one location to another.

The problem

The organisation set out to:

  • Establish a compensation system applicable across all locations
  • Build a job architecture to bring structure to a large, unstructured set of positions
  • Introduce market-oriented benchmarking
  • Enable equal pay analysis within the gradar system

Why it mattered at that point

Years of merger activity had left the organisation with inconsistent grading and pay practices across sites, making it hard to ensure fairness, compare roles or benchmark against the market. Creating one defensible framework across all locations was therefore a foundation for fairness, governance and future pay transparency work.

02 Approach

How the project was delivered

Three connected phases over several years: grading, negotiations and implementation.

Phase 1

Grading

Roles were evaluated systematically with managers, HR business partners and works councils. 247 positions were graded into eight job families, with parallel expert and management career paths and generic role-level descriptions.

Phase 2

Negotiations

With a works council at each of the five sites, negotiations produced a framework company agreement and agreements on the grading system and the salary-band system, at times conducted site by site.

Phase 3

Implementation

Managers were informed and briefed first, followed by information for employees, initial salary adjustments and a first round of gender pay gap analysis.

Scope at a glance

  • Grading of 247 positions within the gradar tool
  • Design of eight job families
  • Role structure with parallel expert and management career paths
  • Role descriptions for each role
  • Market-oriented benchmarking and salary-band design
  • Negotiation and implementation across multiple works councils
  • A first round of gender pay gap analysis

Two parallel career paths

Expert career: from Administrator and Professional through Specialist, Advisor, Consultant and Expert to Lead Expert.

Management career: from Team Supervisor and Team Manager through Department Manager and Division Manager up to the executive level.

Key decisions
  • How to consolidate many inconsistent positions into eight job families and a coherent grade structure
  • How to separate and define expert and management career paths
  • How to design salary bands that worked across all five locations
  • How to handle employees covered by tariff systems
  • How to structure company agreements (framework, grading system, salary-band system)
  • How and when to communicate changes to managers and employees
Data and inputs
  • Existing positions and titles across the five locations
  • Manager, HR business partner and works council input to grading
  • Generic role-level descriptions and job-family definitions
  • External market data for benchmarking and salary-band design
  • Pay and demographic data for the initial gender pay gap analysis
03 Challenges

What made it difficult

The case is candid about real-world complexity, much of it relating to governance and employee representation.

Multiple works councils with differing interests

With a works council at each of the five locations, interests diverged, and conflict between them meant some negotiations had to be conducted individually rather than collectively.

A heavily legal negotiation

Four lawyers acted on the employee-representative side and one on the employer side, making the process formal and demanding.

Tariff-covered employees

The treatment of staff under collective agreements was a particularly sensitive and emotional point.

Organisational change during the project

A structural redesign ran in parallel, with changes of HR contacts and managers, which added complexity and required continuity.

A long timeline

As the team put it, “good things take time”: the project spanned several years.

How these were managed: through patient, structured negotiation, formal company agreements, and clear communication to managers and employees at implementation.

Stakeholder involvement

Grading actively involved managers, HR business partners and works councils. The negotiation phase centred on the five site works councils and their legal representatives, alongside the employer. At implementation, managers were briefed before employees were informed, so the new structure was understood before it took effect.

04 Results and lessons

What changed

Before
After
Five locations with different payment rules
One compensation and grading framework across all five locations
Many positions but no structure
247 positions in eight job families with parallel expert and management career paths
No market-oriented benchmarking
A market-oriented basis for salary bands
No basis for equal pay analysis
A first gender pay gap analysis completed at implementation

What was delivered

  • A single grading and salary-band system for all five locations
  • 247 graded positions in eight job families
  • Generic role-level descriptions for each level
  • Market-oriented benchmarking and a negotiated salary-band system
  • A framework company agreement, a grading-system agreement and a salary-band agreement
  • Manager and employee communication and initial salary adjustments

Lessons learned

  • Expect negotiation to dominate the timeline. With multiple works councils, it can be longer than the grading itself.
  • Anticipate diverging works council interests. Conflict may force site-by-site negotiations.
  • Handle tariff-covered employees with care. Early, transparent handling helps.
  • Build for continuity. Document decisions and maintain governance across personnel changes.
  • Use job families and parallel career paths to bring order to a merged set of positions.
  • Communicate to managers first to support understanding and acceptance.

Relevant for

  • Financial services and operations organisations with inconsistent, merger-driven pay practices
  • Multi-site organisations needing one grading and salary system across locations
  • Organisations with multiple works councils and strong employee representation
  • Companies with partial tariff coverage seeking a coherent framework
  • Organisations preparing for equal pay analysis and pay transparency

As a best-practice sharing case, outcomes are described qualitatively; further quantified results were not stated.

Explore our job architecture features

Through analytical job evaluation, gradar helps organisations design a clear, consistent job architecture that supports fair, transparent pay decisions.
Businesswoman using a stylus on a digital tablet at a bright office desk with pens and papers.

FAQs

How do you create one grading system across multiple sites?

By evaluating roles systematically against consistent criteria, consolidating positions into a manageable set of job families (here, eight), deriving a clear role structure with defined career paths, and then negotiating common company agreements on the grading and salary-band systems that apply across all locations.

Why are works councils so central to a grading project in Germany?

Grading and salary-band systems typically require formal agreement with employee representatives. Where an organisation has several sites, each with its own works council, their differing interests must be reconciled, sometimes through individual, site-by-site negotiation, which makes this phase a major part of the project.

What is the difference between an expert and a management career path?

A management (people-leadership) path runs from supervisory and team-management roles up to division and executive leadership. A parallel expert (individual contributor) path runs from administrator and professional roles up to lead expert, allowing specialists to progress without taking on people-management responsibility.

How does job grading support equal pay analysis?

A consistent grading structure provides a defensible basis for comparing roles of equal value. Once roles across all locations sit within one framework, the organisation can run a credible gender pay gap analysis, as was done in the first round after implementation.

How should tariff-covered employees be handled?

Sensitively and transparently. In this case, the treatment of employees covered by collective agreements was one of the most emotive topics, and it benefited from careful negotiation within the formal company agreements.

How long does this kind of project take?

It depends heavily on the number of locations, works councils and the complexity of negotiation. This programme ran across several years, with the negotiation phase a significant contributor to the overall timeline.

Build your job architecture with gradar

Job architecture insights are delivered through the gradar platform - connecting job evaluation, compensation analysis and pay transparency in one consistent framework.

Job evaluation

Compensation

Pay transparency